Is Mary Kay A Pyramid Scheme?

Scam Risk is here to help you protect yourself and fight back
By: Scam Risk - Expert Reviewer

Mary Kay? Pyramid Scheme? Who Is Virginia Sole-Smith?

We’re pretty sure the name Mary Kay rings a bell. Of course, it’s been in the cosmetic business long before most of you have been born. Mary Kay Cosmetics is not something to sneeze at — it holds almost the same prestige as the big names in the cosmetics business. Think L’Oreal and Sephora.

It’s another one of those making money online businesses that is centered around selling a saturated membership that supposedly makes you money by selling marked up products. 

It is promoted by people who have every incentive for you to join the company or buy products from them.

It’s supposed to show you how to become a “6 figure network marketer” but most members don’t make money promoting other products.

That’s just the truth…you won’t get rich off a crappy $6 commission

If you want to really get rich online, (at an average of $1,500 per sale PER MONTH), check out our #1 recommendation here.

And while we have to be honest for this review…

Mary Kay does come with some very helpful information to make money online and land some massive commission checks…

However, network marketing as the business model is getting a little saturated for the average person.

At the end, you’ll find answers to some of the most frequently asked questions regarding Mary Kay’s products and multi level marketing in general.

And most importantly, I’ll show you the exact system I used to build my own internet marketing business to over $40,000 a month in mostly passive income.

This system made me swear off network marketing for good, because it uses some of the same skills but in a much more powerful and profitable way!

But more on that later.

For now let’s hop into all things Mary Kay!

Table of Contents

Mary Kay Company Quick Overview:

The company was founded by the late Mary Kay Ash in Texas in 1963. It is a US-based seller of cosmetics that employs the MLM business model to sell its products.

Richard Rogers serves as the Executive Chairman to date. He is also the co-founder and Mary Kay’s son.

David Holl serves as President and Chief Executive Officer.

Mary Kay signs up independent distributors also called beauty consultants to sell and distribute products directly to people in their circle.

The company runs on five continents with over 35 markets. To mention but a few, Canada, United Kingdom, Mexico, China, and all the way down under in Australia.

Mary Kay products

Mary Kay’s product range includes makeup, of course, skincare products, body & sun creams, fragrances, and even “men’s grooming”.

Their bestsellers are the Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover and the TimeWise® Miracle Set®. It includes a moisturizer, a cleanser, sunscreen, and a night solution. The aforementioned Mary Kay products are the popular ones.

Is Mary Kay an MLM?

Yes, Mary Kay is an MLM (Multi-Level Marketing) company that manufactures and sells cosmetic and skin care products. Mary Kay has been in business for many years and their beauty consultants are considered to be pioneers in the beauty industry, which gives them a good edge over other MLM companies.

Some reviews say that Mary Kay is definitely not into affiliate marketing nor does it look like that it is offering services for an affiliate program.

As mentioned earlier, Mary Kay Inc. is an American privately owned multilevel marketing company.

So right off the bat, Mary Kay is upfront that it is a brand that sells cosmetics and beauty products through a network marketing structure.

In MLM businesses, the beauty consultants of Mary Kay sell and distribute the company’s products directly to those within their communities.

These beauty consultants are not employees and thereby do not receive a salary. The business model has been the object of criticism recently.

Several media outlets have investigated multilevel marketing companies and their get-rich-quick plans and services. They deemed it troublesome and somewhat akin to the pyramid scheme structure.

According to Direct Selling News, Mary Kay was the sixth largest network company in the world, with a wholesale volume of a whopping $3.25 USD billion in 2018.

That’s a huge amount of income in the highly competitive beauty industry and can definitely be called a million-dollar business. Perhaps that qualifies them to be considered a cosmetics giant.

When Mary Kay Ash founded the company, she probably never thought she would sell those skin creams like crazy!

Pink Pyramid Scheme rumors

However, despite the tremendous success of Mary Kay, the rumor mill is rife with stories about the company being a pink pyramid scheme.

So, is Kay a pyramid scheme? And is it true that this company founded by Mary Kay Ash with an initial investment of $5,000 USD is not really about empowering women or giving services to them or offering business opportunities but more about leading women into what is called a pink pyramid scheme?

How true is that? How can a company that is over half a century old suddenly turn dubious? Let’s dig further.

What is a pink pyramid scheme?

A pink pyramid scheme is mainly a way of exploiting the salesforce.

Under this business model, the company’s sales staff is encouraged to purchase the products and then sell them to their customers.

For many of the consultants of Mary Kay, the financial returns are often minimal — which is really far away from the huge income that the company claims that women can earn by selling their products.

That’s why many people often ask is Mary Kay a pyramid scam or is Kay a pyramid scheme?

Pink Pyramid Scheme Report of Virginia Sole-Smith

Virginia Sole-Smith posted this report to share her experience with Mary Kay.

Her report is entitled “Pink Pyramid Scheme – How Mary Kay Cosmetics Preys on Desperate Housewives.”

In the report, Smith elaborated on how she encountered Mary Kay products and became involved in the business.

She detailed how members were pushed to sell the products.

She also mentioned that this business is not for the faint of heart.

Other reports show that in spite of the claims that Mary Kay earns an annual sale income of $3 USD billion, its salespeople are in debt with boxes of unsold facial creams, lipsticks, and what-not.

Quite a few of them earn some profit, but most of them don’t.

It looks like the sales director gets the bigger slice of the pie and the sales force just gets the crumbs or none at all. You can’t blame people if they wonder if Mary Kay a pyramid scam or Kay a pyramid scheme.

Now a business where only a few individuals earn decent money while the rest pay to play does sound a lot like a pyramid scheme.

The Federal Trade Commission tells apart between recruiting salespeople to sell a product, which is of course, ideally legal, and making money exclusively through some kind of fees for participation, which actually isn’t.

A fee is somewhat unclear but the FTC has charged some multilevel marketing companies with using pyramid schemes. 


Mary Kay denies it and claims that it is just a simple business model where a person signs an agreement directly with the company, buys the products at a wholesale price, and peddles the product to her customers at a suggested retail price.

The profit is hers to keep. It is basically the person’s choice on how much product she wants to buy from the company and sell to the customers.

It should also be clear that Mary Kay does not use affiliate marketing as claimed by others.

So this brings us to the next question—

Is Mary Kay a Makeup Pyramid Scheme?

The Federal Trade Commission describes a pyramid scheme as a business where the main method of earning money is by recruiting and signing up others in joining the program and charging them fees for participation — not by selling products to the public.


Therefore the quick answer to the question “Is Mary Kay a pyramid scheme?” is NO.

On paper, Mary Kay is not a pyramid scheme. But perhaps, in practice, some say it looks like a pyramid scheme.

How does one join Mary Kay?

To get things underway as a Mary Kay beauty consultant, you’ll need $100USD to acquire the ‘Mary Kay® Starter Kit.’

It comes with retail-sized products to show to friends at parties, samplers that are allocated for your would-be clients, and business supplies and brochures with sales tips.

Mary Kay distributors can earn income through two methods. One, from direct selling to customers, and two, from a commission based on sales made by their downlines.

According to one review, Mary Kay consultants can get paid up to 50% gross profit on products when they sell them to customers at full retail price.

This is what they call an earned discount privilege. However, if you look at the small print or particulars, you will be led to ask the following pertinent question —

Can You Really Make Money Selling Mary Kay?

At first, the company mentions in the fine print that in order to receive the hefty 50% gross profit, which is also known as earned discount privilege, one needs to place a $400 retail order every quarter to sustain an active status and get qualified for it.

Like all the other networking companies in the cosmetic industry, Mary Kay distributors push their cosmetics and skin care products through a party plan or pop-up boutiques or online services using private VIP groups on Facebook or through a social media ad.

Consequently, there’s a lot that comes along with Network Marketing that many people struggle with.

In fact, check out our Top 5 Reason Why Most Network Marketers Fail.

Now, don’t get me wrong…

You can certainly make money with Network Marketing, but if you’re gonna put in the amount of grueling work with this business model (which, trust me, isn’t easy), you might as well bring in some REAL money while you’re learning the ropes.

The program that helped skyrocket my online business to $40,000+ per month is so simple that making money really does become second nature.

How much commission do Mary Kay consultants make?

Mary Kay actually gives a generous commission for all products, as mentioned earlier— 50 percent.

This is a gross revenue percentage that doesn’t account for marketing and business administration paid by the consultant.

Personal earnings or income will vary but an average beauty consultant who is eligible for commissions or bonuses can earn up to $5,569 in sales annually.

That’s not bad for Mary Kay’s consultants.

Again, if you look into the fine print, these numbers do not take into account the business or other related expenses. 

How much do you have to sell to get a Mary Kay car?

Yup. it’s possible to get a Mary Kay car.

Beauty Consultants who achieve the status of Mary Kay Independent Sales Director or higher than that position can in fact earn the use of a Mary Kay career car or incentive travel.

According to their website, “as of December 31, 2019, 62% of the 485 Independent Sales Directors and Independent National Sales Directors participated in the Career Car Program and 42% attended an incentive trip.”

Speaking of cars — you guys have probably heard of the notorious Mary Kay Pink Cadillac? A flashy pink car will definitely appeal to an average woman.

A review says that this is typical with multi-level marketing companies like Mary Kay.

They depend on countless recruitment of new customers who buy inventory packages in order to bring more sales and wealth from the bottom to the top of the, well, multi level marketing structure.

It’s like a device to entice people into the business. So the following question persists…

Is MLM a pyramid scheme?

A lot of people call Mary Kay a product-based pyramid scheme — by that it means many people at the bottom of the pyramid must purchase remarkable amounts of products so that those at the top of the pyramid can receive fat commission checks — win a car and go on a flashy vacation trip.

However, to answer the question of MLM is a scam, let’s discuss the differences between the two.

Multi-level Marketing or networking is essentially a marketing strategy that employs selling products directly to the customers— most often by word of mouth.

The difference between this kind of scheme and a legal MLM program is that there is no actual product that is sold in a pyramid scheme.

So not all MLMs are pyramid schemes. As is true with any venture, your financial gain depends on your ability to sell products or offer services.

Be wary of any company that guarantees you cash for doing nothing. Odds are they are not being honest with you. It’s just a device they use to dupe people.

Is Mary Kay a Pyramid Scheme?

No, Mary Kay is not a Pyramid Scheme. It’s a legitimate cosmetics company with a history of providing quality beauty products to their customers. Although recruiting salespeople is crucial to other Multi-Level Marketing companies, Mary Kay consultants can still make money without recruiting others.

Why is Mary Kay Not Dual Marketing?

Mary Kay’s intention is to depart from being associated as an MLM. And they decided to call their business model a “dual-level marketing” program.

Mary Kay came up with that jargon and surely you ask,

What is dual-level marketing?

So the idea is that there are two sales of the product (company to consultant and consultant to customer) somehow means it’s this made-up term of “dual-level.”

If you look at it deeper, it simply is a multi-level marketing plan.

Perhaps it’s the reason for this next question.

Why is Mary Kay so expensive?

Well probably because its products are of ordinary quality and are well, pricey or overpriced in most peoples opinions. Besides that, women have a ton of choices on the Internet and in the stores.

There’s just no need to go through the hassle of looking up a Mary Kay consultant who will just probably try to sign you up as her downline.

Is Mary Kay a Global Brand?

Technically, yes it is. Their brand products are being sold in over 35 countries across the globe. From the United States to China, Mexico, Russia.

What Is Our Top Recommendation For Making Money Online In 2021?

Our review team has come across a program in the real estate industry that is next level!

Although it’s not real estate in the traditional sense, it’s all digital.

Yup, Digital Real Estate!

Where Mary Kay falls short is in scalability. 

There’s only so much time in a day and there’s only so many people you can reach to sell by yourself.

MLM companies know this!

Which is why they push so hard for you to recruit for your downline…you can’t get rich with it as a one man/woman show.

But what if you could make even more money off of little local websites without having to spend hundreds of dollars on overpriced products and a bunch of time recruiting people to sell under you?

With this digital real estate program, you can make recurring monthly income without constant sales to your friends and constant recruitment!

Sound too good to be true?

Of course it does!

But it isn’t…in fact, business owners wish they had this skill!

All you have to do is build and rank a LOCAL website and forward the jobs off to a business owner in town, you could even email it to them!

This works for literally any service based business, tree service, plumbing, towing, etc. 

How do you get paid and how much?

Simple, after you forward the jobs off to a business owner and he makes some money off of them, you simply ask to make the deal beneficial for each other.

A fair price to charge per lead, depending on the industry is 10-20%…let’s just use the tree service industry for example and go by worst case scenario.

Let’s say you build and rank the site and only 10 jobs a month come in. The average tree service job is anywhere from $500-$2000!

That means at bare minimum you have an asset worth $500 a month!

See why they call it digital real estate now? That’s a rent payment. 

The great thing is how easy it is to scale. You don’t have to worry about:

  • Your upline getting paid before you
  • Begging your friends and family to buy from you
  • Recruiting people all the time

But as it is with Mary Kay… You only get what’s left of the pie if you meet a monthly quota…

The course we recommend actually allows you to collect HUGE FLAT RATE DEALS. Truly passive income!

The training program takes making money online to a whole other level. The owner of the program walks you through how to build and rank a site hand in hand, with the occasional voice over when he is sharing his screen.

You will learn the importance of keywords, website name, how to send call notifications via email, backlinking, etc.

Once the training program is completed you will also have access to a Facebook group much better than the Mary Kay group in our opinion. This group is much more active.

Unlike Mary Kay, where you’re getting maybe $10 per sale, you could be getting 10-20X THAT. 

A business will always want more leads and another job. In fact it doesn’t even matter that the job isn’t coming from their website name…they see it as it is…expanding digital real estate.

Unlike Mary Kay, more people have been able to walk away from their 9-5 job as well. 

Digital real estate allows you to have total passive income with most of your day being spent WITH your friends, NOT selling to them.

Now, I know you probably have tons of questions… 

So, check this out to learn more.

Share This Article:
Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
We will be happy to hear your thoughts

Leave a reply

ScamRisk's #1 Online
Business Recommendation:
You know deep down what you're meant for. Now they will show you how to go get it.
Scam Risk
Logo

Be first in line to read all the new Scam Risk Reports as they're published!

Select the categories that interest you the most

We don't share your information with any 3rd parties and we will never spam you.

ScamRisk.com

Fact Checking Standards

To ensure the highest level of accuracy and the most recent up to date information Scam Risk is regularly audited and fact check by following very strict guidelines. All the content on Scam Risk meets the following criteria.

We use the highest level of authority sources such as: FTC (Federal Trade Commission), ICPEN (International Consumer Protection and Enforcement Network), Academic Associations & Journals are used for research reference while creating this content.

Feel free to contact us if you feel this data is incomplete or questionable.

Report A Scam