Most Expensive Squishmallow (2022 Update)

Most Expensive Squishmallow

Are you familiar with the 90s Beanie Baby craze? Did you have one of the rarest squishmallows?

The Kelly Toy company’s Squishmallows craze is all the rage, except it’s bigger, softer, and squishier.

Adorable squishmallows are so popular that the company claimed in February 2020 that it had sold 50 million.


This Most Expensive Squishmallow review has been thoroughly researched with information and testimonials that are available online to anyone in the public. Any conclusions drawn by myself are opinions.

Pandora The Pegasus
Pandora The Pegasus
Price: $25

Pandora is a light pink pegasus with a fairy floss mane. Her ears, muzzle, and belly are white. She has silver wings and black eyes with curled lashes.

Brigita The Snow Leopard
Brigita The Snow Leopard
Price: $26.09

Squishmallow Brigita is a Target-exclusive plush. She has green spots and a beige outline. This Squishmallow has a tiny pink mouth and loves bagels and making mornings fun.

Jackie The Purple Tulip
Jackie The Purple Tulip
Price: $35.79

Jackie, the Purple Tulip, may resemble a Disney character. She has the same vibe as French Fry Floyd, but she’s a dark purple tulip.

Large pale green leaves, black eyes, and a smiling mouth decorate this limited Squishmallow. Jackie enjoys retro shopping with her sisters.

Connor The Cow
Connor The Cow
Price: $50

Connor is one of the rare Squishmallows that sellers frequently restock because many people like him. His black and white patches, pale horns, and black eyes stand out.

He’s a bike-riding Squishmallow athlete. This squishy was in California (which he considers the coolest place he has ever been to).

Jack & Sally Squishmallows
Jack & Sally Squishmallows
Price: $130

Jack and Sally’s Squishmallows are a must-have for Nightmare Before Christmas fans.

In 2021, Zero and Oogie Boogie Squishmallows were released as part of a Halloween holiday collection. Jack and Sally are the most expensive of the entire collection.

Ronnie Cow Squishmallow
Ronnie Cow Squishmallow
Price: $155

Ronnie Cow is a rare Squishmallow who isn’t a Disney character, retailer, or celebrity. Squishmallow website lists September 19, 2020, as Ronnie Cow’s Squishdate. Ronnie Cow’s 24-inch self likely brought comfort to kids missing their friends while schools were closed.

Blossom The Sheep
Blossom The Sheep
Price: $260

Blossom is a rare sheep Squishmallow toy for a sheep lover. Blossom is a great addition to your Squishmallows collection because he’s not as expensive as the others.

Blossom has a white body, cream-colored face, and gold fluffs. Blossom will never be made again, so this already limited Squishmallow will only become more coveted, which could raise its price.

Chanel The Tan Cinnamon Roll Squishmallow
Chanel The Tan Cinnamon Roll Squishmallow
Price: $450

The Chanel Squishmallow is named for the designer perfume. She’s a light brown pastry covered in white icing. Her head and body are covered in icing with a brown swirl.

Gertrude The Goose
Gertrude The Goose
Price: $450

Gertrude is an adventure-loving Squishmallow. She’s known as “bossy,” but she loves helping others.

Black and grey goose Gertrude has a white belly and black eyes. She’s a Canadian-exclusive Squishmallow.

Lucille The Seal
Lucille The Seal
Price: $500

Lucille debuted in 2018. Her body and flippers are white, but her muzzle, belly, and facial features are grey. According to Squishmallow lore, she loves the water and always finds hidden gems and new creatures when she dives.

Phillipe The Frog
Phillipe The Frog
Price: $530

Phillipe has a green body, a white belly, and two pale pink sparkly hearts on each cheek. His bio says he enjoys playing hopscotch with friends. He’s best friends with Marco, a pink and white hedgehog released as a limited edition Squishmallow for Valentine’s Day 2019.

Price: $550

Avery has a emerald green head, yellow beak, black eyes, brown body, and tan tummy. He’s a member of both the Adventure and Farm squads.

Farm Squad is only six farm animals, including Avery. Avery, the duck, is a left-winger for the Squishmallows rugby team and wants to be a coach.

Jack The Black Cat
Jack The Black Cat
Price: $750

Special edition items often skyrocket in value after their release. The 500th rarest Squishmallow, Jack the Black Cat, fits this description. This black cat squishmallow was the 500th design made, and the first limited-edition Squishmallow sold online.

Mariah The Tie-Dye Lamb
Mariah The Tie-Dye Lamb
Price: $800

Mariah, the Tie-Dye lamb, liked horseback riding and her pony, Bernard. Mariah is a Baby Squad Squishmallow with a rattle. Her body is tie-dyed in a rainbow pattern.

Price: $1,100

Santino the Platypus is a rare Squishmallow. He’s 12″ tall and lights brown except for his dark brown bill, black eyes, and white belly.

According to his biography, Santino’s dad taught him to make blueberry pancakes. Santino the Platypus is among the rarest Squishmallows and sells for $1,100-$1,500 on auction sites.

How To Live Your Very Own “Expensive” Lifestyle In 2022!

If you’re still wondering how anyone can afford these things, here’s a little secret:

You can finance ANYTHING!

Which means most folks aren’t actually paying cash for their expensive Santino Squishmallow.

They’re financing their purchase over a number of years, and paying a much smaller monthly payment.

Even better, in a lot of cases, these people can actually write off this monthly payment as a business expense!

Can you imagine that?

Having the best of everything, living your ideal lifestyle, and getting to do it virtually for free?

Well, now you can!

With Digital Real Estate, you can generate enough monthly passive income to make the monthly payments on your new Santino Squishmallow, have enough time to actually enjoy it, and maybe even write it off completely!

Even if you’ve never made a single dollar online, Digital Real Estate may just be for you.


1) It’s Flexible: got an hour a day? You can do this. Ready to drop everything else and dive in full time? You can do this. Yes, the more time you put in, the faster you see results. But even with a little time each day, you can move the needle in a Digital Real Estate business.

And because this system is so flexible, you don’t have to constantly be working to make more money. It’s called PASSIVE INCOME because if you stop working, the money doesn’t.

Imagine taking 3 months off to just tour around Europe, rent a cabin in the woods to write a book, hike the Appalachian Trail, or live on the beach and surf all day.

This is only possible if you have an income stream that’s not tied to your time.

Jump All In

2) You Own & Control EVERYTHING: Now, when you walk into a room looking and feeling like a boss, your bank account and lifestyle will agree.

With Digital Real Estate, you own the assets, which means you have all the power and all the control.

Feeling Blessed

3) Little To No Startup Costs: It’s possible to get into Digital Real Estate with zero dollars upfront. Because, using the strategies outlined in this program, you can get a client to pay you BEFORE spending a penny out of your own pocket…even before you do any work.

Even without getting paid in advance, you can have your first Digital Rental Property up, running, and generating profits for less than $100.

Lance Lead Gen

4) Easy To Duplicate: Ok, here’s the best part: once you have your first Digital Rental Property up and running, you can literally DOUBLE your income with a few clicks, a couple keystrokes, and a single phone call (and you don’t actually need the phone call).

Remember: each Digital Rental Property is worth $500 to $2,000 a month in semi-passive income (over 95% profit). Every time you decide to create another one and increase your income, it gets easier.

Because you have more knowledge, more experience, more results, and more momentum.


5) Make Money Helping Real People: With Digital Real Estate, you’re actually helping people by solving your clients’ biggest problem:

Small, local businesses need more customers, and with Digital Real Estate, you are unleashing a flood of happy, paying customers for these businesses.

You make money by helping them make money.

Not a big, faceless corporation either…a small business owner who’s using that money to put food on the table for their family, start a college fund for their kids, or take care of a sick parent.

Once you see how Digital Real Estate makes a real impact in the lives of real people, you’ll sleep like a baby with a big smile on your face.

Boss of My Own Future

Now, the choice is yours. You could continue looking at articles for the most expensive beanie baby, or you can start taking steps so one day YOU can actually afford them!

At the same time, you’ll join a community of over 2,000 successful students that are living life on their own terms thanks to Digital Real Estate.

A consistent, reliable, semi-passive stream of income that doesn’t depend on you or your time to keep producing profits.

All while genuinely helping real people who are grateful and happy to pay for it.

If this sounds more like what you want out of life (or if you just want some nice side income), click here to learn more about Digital Real Estate.

From Halloween Squishmallows to Christmas Squishmallows, the Kelly Toy Company topped the Beanie Babies of the 90s.

Some Squishmallows quickly became “rare” due to their comfort and personality. A common Squishmallow is affordable, but the most expensive ones can cost a thousand dollars.

Here’s a quick summary of the 15 most expensive squishmallows.

  1. Santino- $1,100
  2. Mariah The Tie-Dye Lamb- $800
  3. Jack The Black Cat- $750
  4. Avery- $550
  5. Phillipe The Frog- $530
  6. Lucille The Seal- $500
  7. Gertrude The Goose- $450
  8. Chanel The Tan Cinnamon Roll Squishmallow- $450
  9. Blossom The Sheep- $260
  10. Ronnie Cow Squishmallow- $155
  11. Jack & Sally Squishmallows- $130
  12. Connor The Cow- $50
  13. Jackie The Purple Tulip- $35.79
  14. Brigita The Snow Leopard- $26.09
  15. Pandora The Pegasus- $25
Scam Risk