Most Expensive Nickel (2022 Update)

Most Expensive Nickel

The origins of nickel can be traced back to the American Civil War. In 1861, the Southern States seceded from the Union, and the Civil War began. Precious metals such as gold and silver were hoarded due to widespread panic.

You may have purchased a bag of sweets or an ice cream cone with a standard nickel, but the nickels on this list can be used to buy a luxury condominium in New York or the yacht of your dreams.

Some rare nickels can only be seen using a magnifying glass. Collectors use a close-up view to assess conditions, locate mintmarks, and discover unusual variations. Look at these 15 most valuable nickels, which you can identify in museums or at your own home!


This Most Expensive Nickel review has been thoroughly researched with information and testimonials that are available online to anyone in the public. Any conclusions drawn by myself are opinions.

1964 Nickel In God We Trust
1964 Nickel In God We Trust
Price: $275

This coin featured a shield, a large “5” surrounded by a star and ray pattern, and the inscription “In God We Trust.” This shield nickel was manufactured from 1866 to 1883. In the same year, 15 million five-cent nickels are produced, 100 times more than silver half-dimes.

1971-S Jefferson Nickel
1971 S Jefferson Nickel
Price: $780

In 1971, Jefferson nickels were produced in San Francisco. A total of 1,655 proofs were issued without the “s” mintmark. NGC and PCGS have only rated a couple of these “No S” 1971 Jefferson nickel proofs.

1950 Jefferson Nickel
1950 Jefferson Nickel
Price: $17,250

The Jefferson nickel series is the longest-running, and the initial design lasted almost 60 years. This is the third installment to feature a former President, and it also comes up with a new design of five-cent coin. The 1950 Jefferson Nickel sold for $17,200 at Heritage Auctions in 2006.

1937-D Buffalo Nickel–Three Legs
1937 D Buffalo Nickel Three Legs
Price: $97,750

This nickel is considered to be one of the most important coins of the twentieth century. A worker manufactured this die while he tried to clean a coin. The worker cleaned the die beyond the standard to remove these flaws.

1935 Buffalo Nickel–Doubled Die Reverse
1935 Buffalo Nickel Doubled Die Reverse
Price: $104,650

This die variant is the product of shoddy artistry. This is the only coin in the Buffalo nickel series with a major reverse design. Coin enthusiasts looking for a full collection of Buffalo Nickels will constantly come upon these coins.

1924-S Buffalo Nickel
1924 S Buffalo Nickel
Price: $105,000

In circulated conditions, this Buffalo nickel coin is far from rare. Because of the 1,437,000 variations of this coin, it has survived and is still available today. This valuable coin is immensely beneficial due to its exceptional preservation and attractiveness.

1919-S Buffalo Nickel
1950 Jefferson Nickel
Price: $109,250

In 1919, San Francisco Mint struck the majority of Buffalo nickels and they were produced inequitably. However, nearly 7 million 1919-S Buffalo nickels were had. They are available in circulated grades but are extremely rare in well-struck high rates.

1880 Shield Nickel
1880 Shield Nickel
Price: $117,000

Coin enthusiasts may be surprised by these 1880 Shield nickels if they don’t know the Shield series. These coins were only produced for 16,000, making it the lowest series production. In addition, 3,955 proof coins were made for coin collectors at that time.

1918-S Buffalo Nickel
1918 S Buffalo Nickel
Price: $125,350

The United States was in the middle of World War I in 1918. War commodities dominated industrial production, and entertainment venues closed. This could explain why so few uncirculated samples of these nickels are available to coin collectors.

1927-S Buffalo Nickel
1927 S Buffalo Nickel
Price: $125,350

Over 3 million 1927-S Buffalo nickels were produced; hence they are scarcely unusual. A well-circulated coin costs merely a few dollars from a reputable vendor. Uncirculated coins with excellent features are rare.

1867 Shield Nickel–Proof With Rays
1867 Shield Nickel Proof With Rays
Price: $132,250

A proof coin is more appealing to a coin collector. The United States Mint only created proof coins for collectors in the mid-1800s. The mint also altered the reverse design by deleting the rays that contributed to the coin’s low output. Most proof coins in this set had a mintage of 1,000 pieces.

1917-S Buffalo Nickel
1917 S Buffalo Nickel
Price: $138,000

In 1917, Europe was at war, and factories began producing war products. San Francisco’s 1917 Buffalo Nickels were poorly struck. A pristine sample with a detailed strike is rare.

1920-D Buffalo Nickel
1920 D Buffalo Nickel
Price: $138,000

The 1920-D Buffalo nickel’s mintage is under 10 million. It’s rare in circulated and mint conditions. This coin is problem-free and well-struck.

1913-D Buffalo Nickel–Type 2
1913 D Buffalo Nickel Type 2
Price: $143,750

The Buffalo nickel was first manufactured in 1913. The Type I coin includes five cents in the Buffalo on a high mound. The coin’s denomination wore off first.

1913 Liberty Nickel–The Olsen Specimen
1913 Liberty Nickel The Olsen Specimen
Price: $4.5 Million

This nickel is one of the finest grades and has only five examples that make this specimen valuable nickel. It’s unknown why the US Mint created only five of these nickels.

Some researchers believe that mint workers used the Liberty Head Nickels because the Buffalo Nickel Dies were not available at the time of manufacture in 1913. Some people gold-plated them and passed these off as five-dollar gold pieces.

How To Live Your Very Own “Expensive” Lifestyle In 2022!

If you’re still wondering how anyone can afford these things, here’s a little secret:

You can finance ANYTHING!

Which means most folks aren’t actually paying cash for their expensive 1913 Liberty Nickel–The Olsen Specimen. They’re financing their purchase over a number of years, and paying a much smaller monthly payment.

Even better, in a lot of cases, these people can actually write off this monthly payment as a business expense! Can you imagine that? Having the best of everything, living your ideal lifestyle, and getting to do it virtually for free?

Well, now you can!

With Digital Real Estate, you can generate enough monthly passive income to make the monthly payments on your new 1913 Liberty Nickel–The Olsen Specimen, have enough time to actually enjoy it, and maybe even write it off completely!

Even if you’ve never made a single dollar online, Digital Real Estate may just be for you.


1) It’s Flexible: got an hour a day? You can do this. Ready to drop everything else and dive in full time? You can do this. Yes, the more time you put in, the faster you see results. But even with a little time each day, you can move the needle in a Digital Real Estate business.

And because this system is so flexible, you don’t have to constantly be working to make more money. It’s called PASSIVE INCOME because if you stop working, the money doesn’t.

Imagine taking 3 months off to just tour around Europe, rent a cabin in the woods to write a book, hike the Appalachian Trail, or live on the beach and surf all day. This is only possible if you have an income stream that’s not tied to your time.

2) You Own & Control EVERYTHING: Now, when you walk into a room looking and feeling like a boss, your bank account and lifestyle will agree. With Digital Real Estate, you own the assets, which means you have all the power and all the control.

3) Little To No Startup Costs: It’s possible to get into Digital Real Estate with zero dollars upfront. Because, using the strategies outlined in this program, you can get a client to pay you BEFORE spending a penny out of your own pocket…even before you do any work.

Even without getting paid in advance, you can have your first Digital Rental Property up, running, and generating profits for less than $100.

4) Easy To Duplicate: Ok, here’s the best part: once you have your first Digital Rental Property up and running, you can literally DOUBLE your income with a few clicks, a couple keystrokes, and a single phone call (and you don’t actually need the phone call).

Remember: each Digital Rental Property is worth $500 to $2,000 a month in semi-passive income (over 95% profit). Every time you decide to create another one and increase your income, it gets easier. Because you have more knowledge, more experience, more results, and more momentum.

5) Make Money Helping Real People: With Digital Real Estate, you’re actually helping people by solving your clients’ biggest problem: Small, local businesses need more customers, and with Digital Real Estate, you are unleashing a flood of happy, paying customers for these businesses.

You make money by helping them make money.

Not a big, faceless corporation either…a small business owner who’s using that money to put food on the table for their family, start a college fund for their kids, or take care of a sick parent. Once you see how Digital Real Estate makes a real impact in the lives of real people, you’ll sleep like a baby with a big smile on your face.

Now, the choice is yours. You could continue looking at articles for the most expensive nickle, or you can start taking steps so one day YOU can actually afford them! At the same time, you’ll join a community of over 2,000 successful students that are living life on their own terms thanks to Digital Real Estate.

A consistent, reliable, semi-passive stream of income that doesn’t depend on you or your time to keep producing profits. All while genuinely helping real people who are grateful and happy to pay for it.

If this sounds more like what you want out of life (or if you just want some nice side income), click here to learn more about Digital Real Estate.

The US nickel is still in use today and is well recognized for representing former US President Thomas Jefferson.

This review covered the 15 most expensive nickels if this article has inspired you to become a coin collector, begin collecting these nickels immediately!

Here’s a quick review of the 15 most expensive nickels:

  1. 1913 Liberty Nickel–The Olsen Specimen- $4.5 Million
  2. 1913-D Buffalo Nickel–Type 2- $143,750
  3. 1920-D Buffalo Nickel- $138,000
  4. 1917-S Buffalo Nickel- $138,000
  5. 1867 Shield Nickel–Proof With Rays- $132,250
  6. 1927-S Buffalo Nickel- $125,350
  7. 1918-S Buffalo Nickel- $125,350
  8. 1880 Shield Nickel- $117,000
  9. 1919-S Buffalo Nickel- $109,250
  10. 1924-S Buffalo Nickel- $105,000
  11. 1935 Buffalo Nickel–Doubled Die Reverse- $104,650
  12. 1937-D Buffalo Nickel–Three Legs- $97,750
  13. 1950 Jefferson Nickel- $17,250
  14. 1971-S Jefferson Nickel- $780
  15. 1964 Nickel In God We Trust- $275
Scam Risk